RDR2 Herbalist Challenges: How to Complete All 10
The early ranks are quick. Herbalist 7 needs 30 of three plants, Herbalist 9 requires all 43 plant species, and Herbalist 10 finishes with 11 seasoned meat types.
- Challenges
- 10
- Herbalist 2
- 4 berry types
- Herbalist 9
- 43 species
- Pickups count
- With the rank active
- Master Roshi Technique
- Quick and easy
What these labels mean
- Master Roshi Technique
The best trick for completing that objective.
- Quick and easy
The quick route, with the steps needed to keep it simple.
The ten Herbalist Challenges go in order. The early ones are quick, then come the ones that need prep: 7, with 90 plants for five tonics; 9, which makes you pick all 43 species in the game with the Challenge active; and 10, with eleven seasoned meats. Plants you picked before Herbalist 9 was active don’t count, so you’ll have to go back for them. RDR2.org
| Challenge | What matters |
|---|---|
| Herbalist 2 | Pick and eat four berry species |
| Herbalist 4 | Feed five mushrooms to your horse |
| Herbalist 7 | Craft and use five Special Miracle Tonics |
| Herbalist 8 | Craft six poison weapons with Oleander Sage |
| Herbalist 9 | Pick all 43 species after the Challenge is active |
| Herbalist 10 | Season and cook all 11 meat types |
Herbalist 1 — pick six Yarrow
Yarrow, with its red flowers, is everywhere in The Heartlands, New Hanover, Lemoyne and around Horseshoe Overlook. Turn on Eagle Eye so plants light up and pick six; if your satchel is full, eat or sell some to make room.
Herbalist 2 — pick and eat four berry species
Picking isn’t enough: you have to eat one of each of the four, Red Raspberry, Blackberry, Evergreen Huckleberry and Wintergreen Berry. GamerGuides Raspberries grow almost everywhere; blackberries in hills and woods like Big Valley; huckleberries along the Kamassa River, in Lemoyne and Roanoke Ridge; and wintergreen in northeastern Ambarino and New Hanover, Cumberland Forest and the colder north. RDR2.org Look at bushes from a distance, since the berries usually show.
Herbalist 3 — craft seven items using Sage
Quick and easyAny sage counts and you can craft the same item seven times. The easy way is Hummingbird Sage, common in Lemoyne, western West Elizabeth and along the Kamassa, with a recipe like Potent Bitters; if your tonic slots fill up, use one and keep going. RDR2.org suggests crafting seven poison arrows or knives with Oleander Sage, which is also a sage. RDR2.org
Herbalist 4 — pick five mushrooms and feed them to your horse
Quick and easyYou don’t need five species: five of the same mushroom work. Chanterelles are common in Lemoyne and eastern New Hanover, Ram’s Head in the woods of West Elizabeth and Ambarino and Parasol mushrooms almost everywhere. Pick them, stand by your horse, open its item wheel and feed it a mushroom five times; you can also feed it while riding at low speed. Mushrooms you were already carrying count, as long as you feed them with the Challenge active.
Herbalist 5 — craft nine items using Indian Tobacco
Quick and easyVery easy: Potent Snake Oil needs just one Indian Tobacco, which grows in the woods and savannas of Ambarino, Lemoyne and West Elizabeth, near Horseshoe Overlook. Pick nine, craft nine oils at camp and, if your satchel fills up, use one and keep going. RDR2.org
Herbalist 6 — pick 15 different herb species
This one is about variety, no perfect route needed: as you travel, turn on Eagle Eye, pick different species and watch the counter until you hit fifteen. Don’t strip the map of orchids: they’re tied to Duchesses and Other Animals, and some stop spawning freely as you approach what that mission asks for. You have plenty of plants for 6 without them; save the serious orchid run for Herbalist 9.
Herbalist 7 — craft and use five Special Miracle Tonics
It looks short but needs a lot of plants. Each Special Miracle Tonic takes Yarrow, Burdock Root and Golden or Black Currant; GamerGuides puts it at 30 of each for all five, and RDR2.org gives a smaller Burdock count per tonic, so 30 covers you. GamerGuides You also have to use all five: crafting them and leaving them in your satchel doesn’t finish the Challenge, and only tonics you craft count.
The recipe is sold by fences after A Short Walk in a Pretty Town, and it’s also in a lockbox beside a bloodstained camp southeast of Vetter’s Echo in Big Valley. Owning the pamphlet isn’t enough: open Satchel → Documents → Recipes and read it, or the recipe won’t show up.
Yarrow is plentiful in The Heartlands and around the oil fields east of Valentine; Burdock grows along riverbanks like the Dakota; and there’s Blackcurrant near Annesburg and Golden Currant in Roanoke Ridge and, after the story, on the plains around Beecher’s Hope. You don’t need all 90 at once: gather enough for one tonic, craft it, use it and keep going. The Ingredients Satchel or the Legend of the East Satchel make it much easier.
Herbalist 8 — use Oleander Sage to craft six poison weapons
You need Oleander Sage, which is poisonous and easy to confuse with regular sage, and grows in the swamps north of Saint Denis, especially around Bayou Nwa. Craft six Poison Throwing Knives or six Poison Arrows, each from its base weapon plus one Oleander. Fences sell the Poison Arrow recipe after Chapter 2, and it’s also in a chest by the Mysterious Hill Home northeast of Bacchus Station; the Poison Throwing Knife recipe is sold after Pouring Forth Oil and sits under a floorboard in a shack northeast of Saint Denis. RDR2.org
Herbalist 9 — pick one of every herb species
The big one: all 43 plants in the game, orchids included, picked with Herbalist 9 active. The ones you picked earlier don’t count, so you have to go back for one of each species. GamerGuides PowerPyx The game shows total progress but doesn’t list which ones you already have, so check each off as you pick it and don’t trust your memory at number 38.
Same care with orchids as in 6: don’t pick them at random for hours before starting the exotics mission, because some have spawn limits tied to that strand. If one seems to have vanished from the map, check your progress in Duchesses and Other Animals.
All 43 plants
Herbs and plants
- Alaskan Ginseng
- American Ginseng
- Blackcurrant
- Burdock Root
- Common Bulrush
- Creeping Thyme
- Desert Sage
- English Mace
- Golden Currant
- Hummingbird Sage
- Indian Tobacco
- Milkweed
- Oleander Sage
- Oregano
- Prairie Poppy
- Red Sage
- Vanilla Flower
- Violet Snowdrop
- Wild Carrot
- Wild Feverfew
- Wild Mint
- Yarrow
Berries
- Blackberry
- Red Raspberry
- Evergreen Huckleberry
- Wintergreen Berry
Mushrooms
- Bay Bolete
- Chanterelle
- Parasol Mushroom
- Ram’s Head
Orchids
- Acuna’s Star Orchid
- Cigar Orchid
- Clamshell Orchid
- Dragon’s Mouth Orchid
- Ghost Orchid
- Lady of the Night Orchid
- Lady Slipper Orchid
- Moccasin Flower Orchid
- Night Scented Orchid
- Queen’s Orchid
- Rat Tail Orchid
- Sparrow’s Egg Orchid
- Spider Orchid
Total: 43.
Herbalist 9 as Arthur
This is where the New Austin problem shows up. Several plants are in an area Arthur can’t normally enter without the game trying to kill him; there are four: Desert Sage, Red Sage and Blackcurrant, which only grow in New Austin according to RDR2.org, and Wild Feverfew, which doesn’t grow outside New Austin either. Shacknews The normal way is to wait until New Austin opens in the Epilogue, where they’re easy to find around Blackwater and Armadillo. The community also uses buggy, wagon or carcass-cover methods to do it as Arthur; if you’re going for Legend of the East as Arthur, follow its guide.
Herbalist 10 — season and cook all 11 meat types
After 9, this one is much friendlier. You have to cook eleven different meat types seasoned with Wild Mint, Oregano or Creeping Thyme; any of the three works. When you pick the meat at the campfire, press left or right on the D-pad to season it, cook it and check it off your list: unseasoned meat doesn’t count. Mint grows by streams and marshes, Oregano in dry grassland and Thyme in sandy soil, riverbanks and rocks. RDR2.org
A campfire in an official Red Dead Redemption 2 image. Rockstar Games.
All 11 meats
| Meat | Where it comes from |
|---|---|
| Exotic Bird Meat | Pelican |
| Tender Pork Loin | Pig or boar, or the butcher |
| Plump Bird Meat | Turkey, goose or chicken |
| Big Game Meat | Alligator, bear, cougar or wolf |
| Prime Beef Joint | Cow, bull or bison, or the butcher |
| Succulent Fish Meat | Small salmon or trout |
| Game Meat | Rabbit, duck or pheasant |
| Flaky Fish Meat | Large fish, like pike in the northern rivers |
| Crustacean Meat | Crab |
| Gristly Mutton | Sheep, ram or goat |
| Mature Venison | Deer, elk or pronghorn, or the butcher |
Buying pork, beef and venison from a butcher saves you three hunts. GamerGuides
Do not forget Crustacean Meat
It’s the meat people forget most. Look for crabs on the islands of Flat Iron Lake, for example off Clemens Point, pick one up and break it down in your satchel to get the Crustacean Meat; then season and cook it.
Herbalist route
1 to 6 are about picking things; 7 is 30 + 30 + 30 plants; 8, six Oleander weapons; 9, the 43-plant checklist; and 10, the eleven-meat list. Don’t try to keep 9 and 10 in your head: make lists.
Unlocks
| Rank | Trapper gear |
|---|---|
| Herbalist 1 | Off-hand holster |
| Herbalist 3 | Gun belt |
| Herbalist 7 | Holster |
| Herbalist 10 | Bandolier |
Completing the set gives a Dead Eye bonus, and the other ranks give cash and Health XP. RDR2.org
Frequently asked questions
How many plants are in Herbalist 9?
43, orchids included. You have to pick one of each species after the Challenge is active.
Do plants I already picked count?
Not for Herbalist 9: you have to pick them again with the Challenge active.
Can I do Herbalist 9 as Arthur?
Not normally, because it needs plants from New Austin. There are community methods with a buggy and other tricks.
How many plants do I need for Herbalist 7?
With 30 Yarrow, 30 Burdock Root and 30 Currants, Golden or Black, you have plenty for all five tonics.
Do I only need to craft the tonics?
No, you have to craft and use them.
Does Herbalist 4 need five different mushrooms?
No, five of the same species work.
Which meat do people forget in Herbalist 10?
Crustacean Meat, which comes from crabs.
More Challenge guides
Sources
RDR2.org — Herbalist Challenge Guide
GamerGuides — Herbalist Challenges
PowerPyx — Red Dead Redemption 2 Plants Locations
Shacknews — Wild Feverfew locations
Red Dead Wiki — Herbalist Challenges
Red Dead Wiki — Plant Gathering
Last verified: October 17, 2026.