RDR2 Sharpshooter Challenges: Fast Methods for All 10
Hanging Dog Ranch covers distance, headshots and disarms; Bluewater Marsh and Twin Stack Pass cover birds, and the Valentine train station covers hats. Sharpshooter 9 needs all three hats in the same Dead Eye, and Sharpshooter 8 breaks if Dead Eye reloads your gun.
- Challenges
- 10
- Main location
- Hanging Dog Ranch
- Birds
- Bluewater Marsh
- Hats
- Valentine / Saint Denis
- Master Roshi Technique
- Quick and easy
What these labels mean
- Master Roshi Technique
The best trick for completing that objective.
- Quick and easy
The quick route, with the steps needed to keep it simple.
The ten Sharpshooter Challenges unlock in order, and nearly the whole set fits in three areas: Hanging Dog Ranch for distance, headshots and disarms, Bluewater Marsh or Twin Stack Pass for birds and the Valentine train station for hats. The ones that stall people most are Sharpshooter 8, because Dead Eye can reload your gun and break the attempt, and Sharpshooter 9, which needs all three hats in a single Dead Eye. RDR2.org
| Area | Use it for |
|---|---|
| Twin Stack Pass and The Heartlands | Sharpshooter 1, 2, 5 and 10 |
| A moving train | Sharpshooter 3 |
| Hanging Dog Ranch or Shady Belle | Sharpshooter 4, 6, 7 and 8 |
| Valentine train station | Sharpshooter 9 |
My video guide to all 10
I published this guide (in Spanish) in November 2018. The written route follows the same methods and adds community alternatives and fixes for when the counter doesn’t move.
Watch the full guide on YouTube. The video goes back over Challenges I had already completed, which is why the completion notice doesn’t pop up; check your progress in the game menu.
Sharpshooter 1 — kill three flying birds
My favorite spot is Twin Stack Pass in The Heartlands, where you can do most of the set: look up and drop three birds while they’re flying, with or without Dead Eye. RDR2.org suggests the herons in the swamps north and west of Saint Denis, in Bluewater Marsh, because they’re slow: one shot in the air gets them flying and Dead Eye takes all three. Use a gun that won’t make you reload halfway, like a revolver or a Lancaster. RDR2.org
If it doesn’t count: the bird has to die in flight; perched birds don’t count.
Sharpshooter 2 — kill two different animal species in the same Dead Eye
Without leaving Twin Stack Pass you’ll find birds, deer and hares. When you have two species in view, activate Dead Eye, tag one animal of each and fire. The Dakota River to the west has geese and deer together and makes it even easier, and if you only find one species, a bird works as the second.
If it doesn’t count: two animals of the same species don’t work.
Sharpshooter 3 — kill five flying birds from a moving train
Quick and easyBoard a train with a ticket or jump on from your horse away from towns, get into an open car or onto the roof and drop five birds while the train is moving. Guards will come for you if you ride without a ticket, so deal with them first. In the video I bought a ticket at Emerald Ranch, got off and climbed back onto the roof from my horse; you can also bribe the engineer and let the train run on its own. RDR2.org
If you still have the Billy Midnight mission, use it: it puts you on a moving train without robbing one, as players explain on Reddit.
If it doesn’t count: the train has to be moving when you shoot.
Sharpshooter 4 — kill with a tomahawk from at least 80 feet
Quick and easyTomahawks are sold by fences, which open after The Spines of America in Chapter 2 (the first one at Emerald Ranch), and the target has to be an enemy at a gang hideout, not any random townsperson. RDR2.org In the video I did it at the O’Driscoll camp at Twin Stack Pass, and Hanging Dog Ranch works just as well.
The trick is to use the aiming reticle as a ruler, as explained on the RDR2.org forums:
- Save your game.
- Aim at the enemy with the tomahawk until the circle turns red.
- Back up in a straight line until it turns white, then step forward until it’s red again.
- Activate Dead Eye, tag the target and throw.
With a guard who isn’t marked as an enemy, like the one at the Cornwall Kerosene & Tar refinery, the Challenge may not count even from farther away. If it doesn’t work the first time, reload your save and try again.
Sharpshooter 5 — kill six animals without reloading or changing weapons
Bring a Lancaster with a full magazine. RDR2.org recommends a remote farm southwest of Flatneck Station, since farm animals move less. RDR2.org In the video I did it at Twin Stack Pass by tagging six or seven birds in one Dead Eye, and the Emerald Ranch chicken coop with dual pistols works too.
If it doesn’t count: you reloaded or switched weapons; start over with a full magazine.
Sharpshooter 6 — kill an enemy from at least 660 feet
Quick and easyThe Challenge needs a long-scoped rifle: buy the Rolling Block from the gunsmith and add the long-range scope. RDR2.org uses the Lemoyne Raiders hideout at Shady Belle for its open sightlines. RDR2.org In the video I climbed the highest rock at Twin Stack Pass, above the road from Flatneck Station to Valentine, and waited for someone to ride by: with the bullet cam the kill lands on the first shot.
As with the tomahawk, aim, back up until the target is almost out of range, step forward a little and fire. If it doesn’t count, you’re too close: back up farther.
Sharpshooter 7 — seven consecutive headshots
There’s no time limit, but a miss, a shot that isn’t to the head or a weapon switch resets the chain. With the Lancaster and a full Dead Eye meter you can get all seven in one activation. Hanging Dog Ranch, Shady Belle or any hideout with enough enemies works; in the video I used the refinery workers.
If it doesn’t count: if you’re unsure about a shot, treat the streak as broken and start another.
Sharpshooter 8 — disarm three enemies without reloading or switching weapons
Master Roshi TechniqueTo disarm someone, shoot the hand or arm holding the gun; body shots kill them first. The catch is that Dead Eye reloads your gun when you activate it, and a reload breaks the attempt. There are two ways around it:
- All three in one Dead Eye, as in the video: provoke the refinery guards with a couple of shots, activate Dead Eye with a loaded Lancaster and get all three disarms in that activation.
- No Dead Eye at Hanging Dog Ranch, the method that comes up most on Reddit: with the Varmint Rifle, which does little damage and holds lots of rounds, shoot the entrance guard’s hand until he drops his gun, ride away until the ranch resets, come back and repeat three times without reloading or switching weapons.
Reddit also has an alternative with a bow and poison arrows aimed at the limbs; it counts for some players and not for others.
If it doesn’t count: check whether you reloaded, switched or holstered your weapon between attempts, whether Dead Eye reloaded it, or whether the enemy died before dropping the gun.
A gunfight in an official Red Dead Redemption 2 image. Rockstar Games.
Sharpshooter 9 — shoot three hats off people in the same Dead Eye
Master Roshi TechniqueThe Challenge needs all three hats in a single Dead Eye activation, and the person has to survive: you’re knocking the hat off, not killing. RDR2.org The best spot I found is the Valentine train station: there are usually two townsfolk with hats leaning on the woodwork and a third who walks out of the station past the stairs in front of them. Activate Dead Eye, tag the top of all three hats and fire. If they’re not there, ride around town and come back. In my game it got easier after Urban Pleasures (Chapter 4), when Dead Eye let me keep firing freely within the activation.
On Reddit players suggest a shotgun from a distance, on the hill facing the station, so the pellets knock hats off without killing; remember all three still have to drop within the same Dead Eye.
Sharpshooter 10 — kill three flying birds with three consecutive long-scope rifle shots
The most tedious one in the set. Use a rifle with a short-range scope, which is easier to handle, and don’t get too far from the flock. Any riverbank has ducks and geese that take off as you approach; I went back to Twin Stack Pass. Activate Dead Eye when you see three birds in the air and fire: a miss breaks the chain, so pick big birds with a predictable flight path.
Fast route for all ten
Start at Twin Stack Pass for Sharpshooter 1, 2 and 5, get on a train for 3, do 4, 6, 7 and 8 at Hanging Dog Ranch or Shady Belle, 9 at the Valentine train station and head back to a river or Bluewater Marsh for 10. They’re not the only places that work, but they save you trips.
Sharpshooter rewards
Ranks 1, 3, 7 and 10 unlock the pieces of the reinforced Sharpshooter set at the trapper: the bandolier at Sharpshooter 1 and the holster at Sharpshooter 3. Completing the set and wearing it gives a permanent Health boost, and the other ranks give cash and Dead Eye XP. RDR2.org How this fits into getting your stats to level 10 is in the 100% guide.
Frequently asked questions
How do I do Sharpshooter 8?
Either get all three disarms in one Dead Eye from a full magazine, or go to Hanging Dog Ranch with the Varmint Rifle and no Dead Eye, disarm the entrance guard, ride away so the ranch resets and repeat.
Can Dead Eye mess up Sharpshooter 8?
Yes, because it reloads your gun when you activate it.
Can Sharpshooter 9 be done across several Dead Eyes?
No. All three hats have to drop in the same activation.
Where do I do Sharpshooter 9?
At the Valentine train station, with the townsfolk who usually wait by the stairs.
Where do I get the 660-foot kill?
At Shady Belle, at Hanging Dog Ranch or from the rock at Twin Stack Pass above the Flatneck Station road.
Where do I find easy birds?
At Twin Stack Pass and in Bluewater Marsh.
Can I do Sharpshooter 3 during Billy Midnight?
Yes, as long as the mission is still available.
More Challenge guides
Sources
Daykyri’s video guide, published in November 2018
RDR2.org — Sharpshooter Challenge Guide, part 1
RDR2.org — Sharpshooter Challenge Guide, part 2
RDR2.org Forums — Sharpshooter 4
Red Dead Wiki — Sharpshooter Challenges
Reddit — Billy Midnight method for Sharpshooter 3
Reddit — Hanging Dog Ranch and Varmint Rifle for Sharpshooter 8
Reddit — poison arrow alternative for Sharpshooter 8
Reddit — Valentine method for Sharpshooter 9
Last verified: October 17, 2026.