dKDaykyri
Red Dead Redemption 2 RDR2ChallengesSurvivalist

RDR2 Survivalist Challenges: How to Complete All 10

Survivalist mixes fishing, hunting and crafting. Do rank 5 near Saint Denis, rank 7 with eight consecutive Small Game Arrow kills and rank 10 with all 15 fish species.

Challenges
10
Survivalist 4
Learn the recipes
Survivalist 7
Small Game Arrows
Survivalist 8
Read the pamphlets
A cowboy rests beside a campfire with his horse behind him in Red Dead Redemption 2
Camping and survival in Red Dead Redemption 2.

Survivalist mixes fishing, hunting and crafting, and its ten Challenges go in order. The ones that usually need a real guide are 5, one fish from a boat and another from the tracks; 7, eight small-game kills in a row without missing; 8, four weapon recipes; and 10, all fifteen fish species. RDR2.org

ChallengeMethod
Survivalist 4Buy or find the recipes before crafting
Survivalist 5A rowboat in Bayou Nwa and the Saint Denis tracks
Survivalist 6A carcass and the scavengers
Survivalist 7Rats or frogs with Small Game Arrows
Survivalist 8Read all four pamphlets
Survivalist 9A legendary fish or a big fish at Lagras
Survivalist 10A 15-species checklist

First: unlock fishing

Survivalist depends on fishing, which unlocks when you complete A Fisher of Men in Chapter 2. From there you can use the rod and start with Bluegill.

Survivalist 1 — catch three Bluegill

Bluegill are among the most common fish and show up in almost any calm water, like Flat Iron Lake or the Dakota River. Use cheese as bait and catch three. RDR2.org

Survivalist 2 — hand five animals in to camp or the Trapper

They don’t need to be five species or perfect: hand in five animals to Pearson at camp or to any trapper. For the trapper, bring your horse close to the shopkeeper; your horse holds roughly one mid-sized animal, like a wolf or deer, or two small ones, like rabbits or birds, and squirrels and rats fit in Arthur’s satchel. RDR2.org Pair it with the hunting you’re already doing for satchels or upgrades.

Survivalist 3 — kill five animals with a Varmint Rifle

The story never hands you the Varmint Rifle: buy it at any gunsmith and kill five small animals, like rabbits, rats or birds. No perfect pelts needed, though it’s the only gun that gets them on varmints; rabbits are common by the roads and one headshot does it. RDR2.org

Survivalist 4 — craft all five required arrow types

You need to craft one of each: Dynamite, Fire, Improved, Poison and Small Game. They all take an arrow and a flight feather, plus one extra ingredient:

ArrowExtra ingredient
Dynamite ArrowDynamite
Fire ArrowAnimal fat
Improved ArrowNone
Poison ArrowOleander Sage, from the swamps near Saint Denis
Small Game ArrowA regular shotgun shell

Fences sell the recipes after The Spines of America in Chapter 2. RDR2.org You can also find them in the world: the Dynamite Arrow pamphlet is near the south end of the Wapiti reservation, by a bridge, and the Poison Arrow one is northeast of Bacchus Station. When you pick up a pamphlet, open it under Satchel → Documents → Recipes and read it, or Arthur won’t learn the recipe. While you’re at it, craft at least eight Small Game Arrows, since you’ll need them for Survivalist 7.

Survivalist 5 — catch a fish from a boat in the Bayou and while standing on railroad tracks

Two fish: one from a boat and one standing on the tracks. For the boat, there’s usually a rowboat around Hagen Orchards, southwest of Lagras: get in, row into Bayou Nwa and catch any fish. If a canoe doesn’t count for you, find a rowboat, which is the safest option.

For the tracks, go to the ones crossing the water south and southwest of Saint Denis and stand inside the tracks, between the rails, before you cast. From the edge of the bridge you can fish without the game registering that you’re on the tracks. And look before you start, because trains don’t slow down for Arthur fishing.

Survivalist 6 — kill five scavengers while they are feeding on a corpse

The animal has to be eating when you kill it. Kill something in the open, leave the carcass, back off and wait for crows, vultures, coyotes or other scavengers. If one just landed and isn’t eating yet, wait: shoot when it’s clearly on the carcass. Five times.

Survivalist 7 — kill eight small-game animals with consecutive Small Game Arrow shots

Consecutive matters here: you need eight one-shot kills with Small Game Arrows, and the streak breaks if you miss, wound without killing, waste an arrow on an animal that isn’t small game or kill small game with another weapon. Take eight easy shots, not eight pretty ones.

Rat method

Master Roshi Technique

The cave behind Elysian Pool has rats: they’re small, close together and they don’t fly. Equip the bow with Small Game Arrows, go in slowly, get close to each rat and only shoot when the shot is clear; you have all the time in the world. The alternative is the frogs and toads in the wetlands north of Saint Denis, which barely move, though watch your step there because there are alligators too.

A cowboy rests beside a campfire with his horse behind him in Red Dead Redemption 2 Camping and survival in an official Red Dead Redemption 2 image. Rockstar Games.

Survivalist 8 — craft four special weapons

You need to craft a Homing Tomahawk, an Improved Tomahawk, Volatile Dynamite and a Volatile Fire Bottle, and each one needs its pamphlet read first:

WeaponIngredientsWhere the pamphlet is
Improved TomahawkTomahawk and an eagle or hawk featherLearned early in the story
Homing TomahawkTomahawk and an owl featherShack south of Moonstone Pond, or fences
Volatile DynamiteDynamite, animal fat and a high velocity cartridgeUnder a broken wagon at Hani’s Bethel, or fences
Volatile Fire BottleMoonshine and animal fatAbandoned camp northwest of Horseshoe Overlook, or fences

Owls come out at night on posts, roofs and ruins; a fairly reliable spot is the Old Trading Post, near Flatneck Station. Go at night and look up.

Survivalist 9 — catch a fish that weighs at least 19 lbs

What counts is weight, not species. The easiest way is a legendary fish if you still have one left. If you’ve caught them all, look for big species like Lake Sturgeon, Muskie, Northern Pike, Longnose Gar or Channel Catfish around Lagras and Bayou Nwa, with a swamp or big-fish lure. If it comes in under 19 lbs, release it and keep going: weight varies.

Survivalist 10 — catch one of every fish species

That’s 15 regular species, no legendaries needed, and only what you catch with the Challenge active counts: a species you discovered fifty hours ago isn’t added. Watch the Challenge counter and keep a checklist. RDR2.org

15-fish checklist

FishUseful bait or lure
BluegillCheese
Bullhead CatfishCorn
Chain PickerelCorn
Channel CatfishSwamp Lure
Lake SturgeonLake Lure
Largemouth BassCrayfish
Longnose GarSwamp Lure
MuskieLake Lure
Northern PikeRiver Lure
PerchBread
Redfin PickerelBread
Rock BassCheese
Smallmouth BassCricket
Sockeye SalmonRiver Lure
Steelhead TroutWorm

A practical route: at Lagras and Bayou Nwa, the catfish, gar, Chain Pickerel and sturgeon; at Flat Iron Lake, both bass, Bluegill, Rock Bass and Steelhead Trout; in the northern rivers, the salmon, pike, perch and muskie; and the Redfin Pickerel in southern waters and rivers, with bread. If a fish won’t show, change one thing at a time: the type of water, the bait, a few yards of position or the time of day.

Unlocks

RankTrapper gear
Survivalist 1Gun belt
Survivalist 3Off-hand holster
Survivalist 7Bandolier
Survivalist 10Holster

Completing the set gives a permanent Dead Eye bonus, and the other ranks give cash and Stamina XP. RDR2.org

Frequently asked questions

How do I unlock the Survivalist Challenges?

Progress until fishing unlocks with A Fisher of Men and start by catching Bluegill.

Where do I do Survivalist 5?

With a rowboat in Bayou Nwa and on the tracks south and southwest of Saint Denis.

Why doesn’t my fish from the tracks count?

Stand inside the tracks, between the rails; from the edge of the bridge it may not count.

What’s the easy way to do Survivalist 7?

The rats in the Elysian Pool cave or the frogs and toads near Saint Denis, using only Small Game Arrows and without missing.

What happens if I miss in Survivalist 7?

The streak resets.

Where do I get owl feathers?

Hunt owls at night; the Old Trading Post near Flatneck Station is a good area.

What’s the easy way to do Survivalist 9?

A big legendary fish. If you have none left, look for sturgeon, muskie, pike, gar or channel catfish.

How many fish does Survivalist 10 need?

15 regular species.


More Challenge guides

All RDR2 Challenges

Herbalist

Horseman

Master Hunter

Explorer


Sources

RDR2.org — Survivalist Challenge Guide

GameFAQs — Survivalist Challenges

Red Dead Wiki — Survivalist Challenges

Last verified: October 17, 2026.