RDR2 Missables: Chapter-by-Chapter Checklist
Official Total Completion can largely be cleaned up after the story, but a truly complete save has missable content. Keep a manual save at the start of every chapter.
- Before advancing
- Manual save
- Chapters 2–4
- Companion activities
- Errand Boy
- 5 requests
- Honor
- Optional missions
- Master Roshi Technique
- Quick and easy
What these labels mean
- Master Roshi Technique
The best trick for completing that objective.
- Quick and easy
The quick route, with the steps needed to keep it simple.
RDR2’s official 100% doesn’t require any missable content: you can finish the story and keep cleaning up Total Completion. A playthrough where Arthur has seen and done almost everything is different, and there you can miss companion activities, camp requests, optional missions, unique weapons, hats, documents, Guarma animals, scenes and some trophies or achievements. The safest way to play is to make a manual save at the start of every chapter and never overwrite it.
Quick answer
| If you care about… | Do this |
|---|---|
| Only official 100% | You can clean up almost everything after the story |
| Friends With Benefits | One companion activity in Chapters 2, 3 and 4 (table games don’t count) |
| Errand Boy | Deliver 5 camp requests before finishing Chapter 4 |
| Give to the Poor | Donate $250 total to the camp box in Chapters 2 to 4 |
| Lending a Hand | Do every optional Honor mission when it appears |
| Breaking and Entering | Rob four homesteads early |
| Full Compendium | Study Guarma’s exclusive animals |
| Unique weapons | Pick them up when they appear |
The rule that prevents most mistakes
Quick and easyWhen you reach a new camp, save, talk to people, sleep and come back at different times, do the white activities that show up, hand in pending requests and don’t chain ten yellow missions without going back to camp. RDR2 hides a lot behind the time of day, whether a character is around or exactly where you are in the story: if something doesn’t show, come back later.
Missable trophies and achievements
Friends With Benefits asks for one companion activity at camp in each of Chapters 2, 3 and 4, not all of them. Table games with the gang don’t count, and if none show up, advance the story or sleep in your tent and try another time of day. PowerPyx
Errand Boy asks you to deliver five item requests from companions between Chapters 2 and 4; do it before Chapter 4 ends. Most are handed out between 8:00 and 20:00, with exceptions: Lenny’s pocket watch, 20:00 to 3:00; Pearson’s rabbit, 8:00 to 12:00; and Kieran’s burdock root, 12:00 to 18:00. Tilly’s necklace and Pearson’s naval compass only come up while playing dominoes or poker with them, and doing a main mission with each companion unlocks more requests. PowerPyx
Give to the Poor asks you to donate $250 total to the camp tithing box in Chapters 2, 3 and 4, not all at once; valuables you donate count too. After Chapter 4 there’s no box and the trophy becomes impossible. PowerPyx
Lending a Hand asks for every optional Honor mission in a single playthrough; replaying them from the menu doesn’t count. You also need Honor level 4 (of 8) before Chapter 6 for Do Not Seek Absolution. The full list goes chapter by chapter below, and it’s worth checking your mission log at the end of each chapter. PowerPyx RDR2.org
Breaking and Entering asks you to rob four homesteads. Do it early, since some are tied to companion activities and others disappear if you kill the owners.
Chapter 1: Colter
There’s little room to explore. The easiest thing to miss is documents inside missions: in Who the Hell is Leviticus Cornwall?, check the last train car and loot it before you get off if you want the Cornwall papers.
Chapter 2: Horseshoe Overlook
This is where the real work starts. For Friends With Benefits, the home robbery with Javier or the bison hunt with Charles count. Requests can come from Abigail, Jack, Javier, Mary-Beth, Pearson, Sean or Dutch; five in total gets you Errand Boy, but in a complete playthrough try to trigger them all.
Pearson’s rabbit request shows up in the morning: bring him an unskinned rabbit. According to Red Dead Wiki, the reward is a unique blue Scout Jacket that many players find out about too late, so don’t leave it for the Epilogue.
The chapter’s Honor missions are Money Lending and Other Sins I to III, with Strauss’s debts (Wrobel, Chick Matthews and Lilly Millet); Good, Honest, Snake Oil, at the Valentine sheriff’s office; We Loved Once and True I to III, which start with Mary’s letter in your tent; and Pouring Forth Oil II, which isn’t an Honor mission but is missable. RDR2.org
Before moving on to Chapter 3, check: one companion activity done, requests and donations on track, Mary and Strauss handled, Pearson if you want the jacket and your Horseshoe Overlook save kept.
Chapter 3: Clemens Point
For Friends With Benefits, the coach robbery with Sean or Bill, fishing with Javier or Kieran or the home robbery with Javier if it comes back all count; Five Finger Fillet with Micah and dominoes with Tilly don’t. The Honor missions are The Course of True Love II and III, from Beau Gray in Rhodes, and Money Lending and Other Sins IV, with the Gwyn Hughes and Winston Holmes debts. PowerPyx
In Magicians for Sport there’s a Rare Rolling Block Rifle: according to Red Dead Wiki, you lose it if you don’t loot the body carrying it during the mission.
Before Chapter 4: one activity done, Strauss handled, the Rare Rolling Block picked up, requests checked and your Clemens Point save kept.
Chapter 4: Shady Belle
It’s the last camp that counts for Friends With Benefits: hunting with Pearson, cattle rustling with Uncle or the coach robbery with Micah or Lenny all work. The bank robbery with Charles is from the Special and Ultimate editions and you don’t need it. It’s also the last chapter for Errand Boy and Give to the Poor.
The Honor missions are Help a Brother Out and Brothers and Sisters, One and All, from Brother Dorkins in Saint Denis; Fatherhood and Other Dreams I and II, with Mary’s letter; and Money Lending and Other Sins V, with the Algie Davidson debt. Do Brothers and Sisters before Sister Calderon leaves for Mexico, because without it you won’t get Of Men and Angels in Chapter 6. PowerPyx
Before Banking, the Old American Art, save and don’t overwrite it: it’s your backup before Guarma, and if you later find you’re missing a macaw, going back there beats replaying half the game.
A camp scene in an official Red Dead Redemption 2 image. Rockstar Games.
Chapter 5: Guarma
If you only want official 100%, you don’t need Guarma’s wildlife, and it doesn’t count for the Skin Deep or Zoologist trophies either. For a full Compendium, stop here: you can’t go back to the island. Look for the Blue and Yellow, Great Green and Scarlet Macaws, the Red-footed Booby and the Red, Rainbow and Sunglow Boas; the Green Iguana and Cuban Land Crab also spawn on the mainland, on the large island in Flat Iron Lake and on the shore west of Rhodes. PowerPyx Guarma’s soldiers can wear a Sun Hat you can keep. The full route is in the Guarma guide.
Chapter 6: Beaver Hollow
This is where many of Arthur’s optional missions pile up, so don’t rush the ending if you’re after Lending a Hand. The Honor missions are Do Not Seek Absolution I and II, from Edith Downes in Annesburg, which only appear at Honor level 4; Of Men and Angels I and II, if you did the Dorkins and Calderon chain; The Course of True Love IV and V, with Penelope’s letter; Archaeology for Beginners, from Rains Fall at the reservation; Honor, Amongst Thieves, from Captain Monroe; Money Lending and Other Sins VI and VII; and Mrs. Sadie Adler, Widow I and II. RDR2.org
According to Red Dead Wiki, in Archaeology for Beginners Rains Fall gives you an Owl Feather Trinket if you recover the items without killing the soldiers, using stealth. And if you start Charlotte Balfour’s strand as Arthur, finish it: leaving it halfway can change what you find in the Epilogue.
Before Our Best Selves, make a manual save and keep it: it’s your end-of-Chapter-6 Arthur with much of the world still open.
What doesn’t affect official 100%
You can miss the Scout Jacket, the Guarma animals, the Sun Hat, the Rare Rolling Block, camp requests or companion activities and still reach 100%: Total Completion doesn’t need them. What does have story windows are the Friends With Benefits, Errand Boy, Give to the Poor and Lending a Hand trophies.
Saves worth keeping
Master Roshi TechniqueIf you have room, keep seven: the start of Chapters 2, 3 and 4, one before Banking, the Old American Art, one during Guarma, the start of Chapter 6 and one before Our Best Selves. It seems like too many until you discover you forgot a snake thirty hours ago.
Minimum checklist to play stress-free
- One companion activity in Chapter 2.
- One in Chapter 3.
- One in Chapter 4.
- Five requests delivered before Chapter 4 ends.
- $250 donated to camp before Chapter 4 ends.
- Honor level 4 before Chapter 6.
- Optional Honor missions as they appear.
- Rare Rolling Block picked up.
- Guarma checked if you want a full Compendium.
- A save before the end of Chapter 6.
Frequently asked questions
Can you miss 100% in RDR2?
No: Total Completion can be finished after the story. What you can miss is optional content and some trophies.
Is Friends With Benefits missable?
Yes. Do one companion activity at the camps in Chapters 2, 3 and 4.
Do table games with the gang count?
No, they have to be activities like hunting, fishing or robbing.
Are Errand Boy and Give to the Poor missable?
Yes, both close when Chapter 4 ends.
What Honor do I need for Lending a Hand?
Level 4 before Chapter 6, for Do Not Seek Absolution.
Are Guarma’s animals needed for 100%?
No, nor for Skin Deep or Zoologist. Only for a full Compendium.
Which save matters most?
One before Banking, the Old American Art and one before Our Best Selves.
More RDR2 guides
What to Do in Guarma Before Leaving
Sources
PowerPyx — Red Dead Redemption 2 Trophy Guide & Roadmap
RDR2.org — Missable Quests Guide
Steam Community — Story Mode Missables
Reddit, r/reddeadredemption2 — Updated 100% Missables Guide
Red Dead Wiki — Missable Content in Redemption 2
Last verified: October 17, 2026.