RDR2 Weapons Expert Challenges: How to Complete All 10
Hogtie enemies to simplify the dynamite and tomahawk ranks, use Thieves' Landing for stealth bow kills and Poison Throwing Knives for the final grizzly.
- Challenges
- 10
- Expert 3
- Corpse and crows
- Expert 6
- Dynamite
- Expert 7
- Recover your tomahawk
- Master Roshi Technique
- Quick and easy
What these labels mean
- Master Roshi Technique
The best trick for completing that objective.
- Quick and easy
The quick route, with the steps needed to keep it simple.
Weapons Expert looks like ten different fights, but several get much simpler with the same pattern: controlled enemies, the right weapon and one condition at a time. Kills have to be enemies: in several ranks regular townsfolk don’t count, so gang hideouts and camps are where you want to be. RDR2.org
| Challenge | Method |
|---|---|
| Expert 2 | Three enemies together and Throwing Knives with a long Dead Eye |
| Expert 3 | A carcass as bait and wait for the birds |
| Expert 6 | Hogtie four enemies and one stick of dynamite |
| Expert 7 | Retrieve the same tomahawk between kills |
| Expert 9 | Thieves’ Landing or stealth at camps |
| Expert 10 | Grizzly and Poison Throwing Knives |
Weapons Expert 1 — kill three enemies with a knife
It has to be the melee knife; Throwing Knives belong to the next Challenge. No need to charge ten armed men: use stealth kills at enemy camps and missions that let you sneak up from behind, and you may well finish it without trying.
Weapons Expert 2 — kill three enemies in ten seconds using only Throwing Knives
Master Roshi TechniqueTime matters here. Throwing Knives are sold by fences, and the mission Paying a Social Call gives them to you and lines up several O’Driscolls conveniently. Fill Dead Eye and drink a Snake Oil to stretch it; RDR2.org recommends a hideout with enemies in the open, like Shady Belle. RDR2.org The most controlled method is to hogtie three camp enemies and leave them together: knife equipped, aim for the head and chain all three without burning the ten seconds running between them.
Weapons Expert 3 — kill three birds of prey using only a tomahawk
Master Roshi TechniqueNo need to chase eagles or do them in a row. Kill an animal in the open, leave the carcass, back off and wait for scavenger birds to land; when one settles, move in, aim until the reticle turns red and throw, with Dead Eye if you like. Pick the tomahawk back up and wait again. RDR2.org also suggests the shore of Owanjila lake, which has eagles. RDR2.org Tomahawks are sold by fences, which open after The Spines of America in Chapter 2.
Weapons Expert 4 — kill ten enemies with a shotgun using crafted ammo
The Challenge checks the shell type, so it has to be crafted shotgun ammo. At any campfire you can make Explosive Slugs from a shell and animal fat, or Incendiary Buckshot from a shell and moonshine. RDR2.org Load it and kill ten enemies at a hideout like Hanging Dog Ranch or Thieves’ Landing, in missions or with the bounty hunters and lawmen who chase you after a crime. Don’t switch to regular shells thinking they count the same.
Weapons Expert 5 — kill five mounted enemies with one Throwing Knife per kill
Quick and easyEach enemy has to be mounted and each kill has to take a single knife; they don’t need to be in a row. Pick up a small bounty, or commit a crime in town and ride until mounted lawmen chase you, then wait for them in the open. With a full Dead Eye and Snake Oil, aim for the head: one knife, one kill, five riders. As Arthur, the Great Plains also fill up with mounted lawmen, though it’s a lot more dangerous.
Weapons Expert 6 — kill four enemies at the same time with one stick of dynamite
Master Roshi TechniqueYou don’t need a miracle throw in the middle of a gunfight. Dynamite is sold by fences. Provoke camp enemies or people on the road, lasso them, hogtie them and carry them one by one to a spot away from towns; with all four together, throw one stick in the middle and get clear. RDR2.org KKK encounters can also bring enough enemies together if you still have one, but hogtying is more controllable.
Weapons Expert 7 — kill four consecutive enemies with the same tomahawk
The key word is same: throw, kill, pick it up and throw it again. The easiest way is to hogtie four enemies, spaced out enough not to mix them up, and repeat throw and pickup four times. If Arthur draws another weapon, don’t kill anyone with it: pick up the tomahawk and equip it again. RDR2.org does it at a hideout: kill one enemy with stealth, retrieve the tomahawk, leave without killing anyone else, wait a few minutes and come back for the next one. RDR2.org
Weapons Expert 8 — kill fifteen enemies with a long-barreled sidearm
It asks for a sidearm —revolver or pistol— with the long barrel fitted at the gunsmith, not a long shotgun. RDR2.org suggests the Volcanic Pistol. RDR2.org The fifteen kills don’t have to be consecutive and hideout and mission kills count. If it doesn’t count, first check that the gun has the long barrel.
A gunfight in an official Red Dead Redemption 2 image. Rockstar Games.
Weapons Expert 9 — kill nine unaware enemies from behind using the bow
Three conditions: unaware enemy, from behind and with a bow. Craft Improved Arrows at camp, from one arrow and one flight feather, since they do more damage and don’t alert the others. RDR2.org During the story, use camps, hideouts and the stealth sections of missions: get behind them and put an arrow in the head. If the enemy turns and goes hostile before you shoot, find another.
Fast Thieves’ Landing method
Master Roshi TechniqueAt the north end of Thieves’ Landing there are Del Lobo guards, and the area reset lets you repeat without finding nine camps: stand at the north side, find a guard with his back to you, kill him with the bow, mount up, ride away until the danger clears and come back, since the guard may have respawned. Repeat. As Arthur it’s better to do it normally in missions and camps, because crossing New Austin just for this isn’t worth it.
Weapons Expert 10 — kill a grizzly without taking damage using only Throwing Knives
Master Roshi TechniqueIt sounds awful, but Poison Throwing Knives make it manageable. They’re crafted from a throwing knife and Oleander Sage, and Improved ones from a knife and two eagle or hawk feathers. RDR2.org There are grizzlies northwest of Wallace Station, in Black Bone Forest and in northern Ambarino.
Save first, spot the bear from a distance with Eagle Eye and keep space between it and Arthur. When you have a clean shot, activate Dead Eye and throw at the head; stay out of reach and, if it’s still alive, reactivate Dead Eye and finish it with another knife. Don’t shoot it with a rifle first or weaken it with another weapon: the Challenge asks you to kill it with Throwing Knives only, and poison ones count.
Fast route
Missions and camps for Expert 1 and 2, a carcass in the open for 3, a hideout for 4, 6 and 7, riders or bounty hunters for 5, any fight for 8, Thieves’ Landing or stealth for 9 and Wallace Station or Big Valley for the grizzly.
Unlocks
| Rank | Trapper gear |
|---|---|
| Weapons Expert 1 | Holster |
| Weapons Expert 3 | Gun belt |
| Weapons Expert 7 | Off-hand holster |
| Weapons Expert 10 | Bandolier |
Completing the set gives a permanent Health bonus, and the other ranks give cash and Health XP. RDR2.org
Frequently asked questions
How do I do Weapons Expert 6?
Hogtie four enemies, put them together and throw one stick of dynamite in the middle.
How do I do Weapons Expert 7?
Kill with a tomahawk, pick it up and kill with the same one, four times in a row.
What ammo counts for Weapons Expert 4?
Crafted shotgun ammo, like Explosive Slugs or Incendiary Buckshot.
Does Weapons Expert 8 ask for a shotgun?
No. It asks for a sidearm, pistol or revolver, with a long barrel.
Where can I do Weapons Expert 9 fast?
At Thieves’ Landing, repeating a stealth bow kill and resetting the area. As Arthur, at camps and in missions.
How do I kill the Weapons Expert 10 grizzly?
With Poison Throwing Knives, keeping your distance, without taking damage and without using another weapon.
More Challenge guides
Sources
RDR2.org — Weapons Expert Challenge Guide
GameFAQs — Weapons Expert Challenges
PowerPyx — Red Dead Redemption 2 Challenges
Red Dead Wiki — Weapons Expert Challenges
Last verified: October 17, 2026.