RDR2 Bandit Challenges: How to Complete All 10
Use Valentine for people and shops, Emerald Ranch for coaches and wagons, Clemens Cove for horses and one passenger per train for Bandit 10.
- Challenges
- 10
- People and shops
- VALENTINE
- Coaches
- EMERALD RANCH
- Horses
- CLEMENS COVE
- Master Roshi Technique
- Quick and easy
What these labels mean
- Master Roshi Technique
The best trick for completing that objective.
- Quick and easy
The quick route, with the steps needed to keep it simple.
The ten Bandit Challenges unlock in order, and most of the set can be done around a few places: Valentine for people and shops, Emerald Ranch for coaches and wagons, Clemens Cove for horses and the trains for traveler money and Bandit 10. Almost every Challenge costs some Honor, so the Honor section explains how to keep Arthur’s ending under control.
Jump to: Bandit 1 · Bandit 2 · Bandit 3 · Bandit 4 · Bandit 5 · Bandit 6 · Bandit 7 · Bandit 8 · Bandit 9 · Bandit 10 · Honor · Not counting · Video
| For | Go to |
|---|---|
| People and shops | Valentine |
| Coaches and wagons | Emerald Ranch |
| Horses | Clemens Cove |
| Traveler money and Bandit 10 | Trains |
You cannot finish the whole set right away. The Emerald Ranch wagon fence opens after The Spines of America in Chapter 2, and the Clemens Cove horse fence opens after Horse Flesh for Dinner in Chapter 3.
My video guide to all 10
I published this guide in 2018. The written route uses the same methods, with the Honor cost of each Challenge, troubleshooting for the counter and a community shortcut for Bandit 10.
Watch the full guide on YouTube. The video is in Spanish and revisits Challenges I had already completed, so some clips do not show the completion notification; check your progress in the game menu.
Bandit 1: hold up five townsfolk
This Challenge in the video · 1:14.
Quick answer: hold up five townsfolk in Valentine with the rob prompt. Shops and travelers on the road do not count, and each person has to hand over their money.
Go to Valentine, where the law is easier to escape than in Saint Denis or Blackwater. Walk up to someone, draw your weapon and use the rob prompt. Some people hand over their money straight away and others need a threat or a warning shot. Unarmed townsfolk give you fewer problems, and a bandana makes witness identification harder without making you invisible to lawmen. Five holdups and the Challenge is done.
Van Horn has almost no formal law, but the townsfolk fight back: pull a gun and half the street may join in. Valentine is easier to control.
Reward: the Bandit Bandolier at the Trapper.
How to unlock Bandit Challenge 1
The Bandit branch opens the first time you hold someone up: rob a townsperson and the Challenge pop-up appears. From then on you can follow it in Progress → Challenges, or with a quick tap of left on the d-pad (holding it opens Arthur’s journal), as players on GameFAQs explain.
Bandit Challenge 1 not working?
Bandit 1 counts people, not shops: robbing store registers does not add to it, as a Steam thread confirms. They also have to be townsfolk in a town, because travelers on the road do not count. The counter moves when the person hands over the money after the rob prompt; if they run, fight back or die before paying, try someone else.
Bandit Challenge 1 without losing Honor
Not possible: every holdup costs a little Honor. Five holdups are a small loss that a few greetings, released fish or a donation to the camp tithing box win back.
Bandit 2: rob two coaches or return two to the fence
Master Roshi TechniqueThis Challenge in the video · 2:36.
This is the Master Roshi technique from my original video. One coach gives you both actions the Challenge counts, robbing the chest and selling the coach:
- Pay for a coach from Valentine to Emerald Ranch.
- Get off when you arrive and steal the same coach that dropped you there.
- If it has a locked chest on the back, shoot the lock or use a lockbreaker from the fence and take something.
- Drive the coach a few yards to the fence and sell it.
Two jobs. One coach.
Use a normal stagecoach: players report that coaches from special jobs, like the post office ones, may not count.
Honor: stealing the coach and robbing its chest both cost some.
Reward: $5 and Dead Eye experience. RDR2.org
Bandit 3: rob four shop registers in one day
Master Roshi TechniqueThis Challenge in the video · 3:37.
Start early in Valentine, because shops close. The general store, the doctor and the gunsmith are close together. Put on the bandana, aim at the clerk, empty the register, leave town, lose the law and come back for the next one. After three registers, ride to Strawberry for the fourth.
Players on Steam use two other routes: one shop per town in the same day (Van Horn, Rhodes, Valentine and Strawberry), so you leave each town’s law behind, or several shops in Saint Denis, escaping the red zone between robberies. Being chased does not affect the Challenge: it only asks for four registers in the same day.
In my run I also tried something else: instead of wasting time escaping, I let the law take me down. You lose a little money, very little in-game time passes (about 30 in-game minutes in my playthrough, which is an observation from that run rather than a guarantee) and you skip the chase.
Honor: robbing a shop register costs much more than stealing a horse, so four in one day add up.
Reward: the Bandit Holster at the Trapper.
Bandit 4: rob three coaches or return three to the fence in one day
Master Roshi TechniqueThis Challenge in the video · 4:50.
This is Bandit 2 on a timer: three times in one day. Take a coach from Valentine to Emerald Ranch, steal it when you get off, sell it straight away and take another coach back to Valentine. You do not need the rear chest this time, only three sales, and Seamus, the Emerald Ranch fence, is close enough to the station for the loop to fit in one day.
Honor: each stolen coach costs some.
Reward: $10 and Dead Eye experience. RDR2.org
Bandit 5: amass a $250 bounty in one state
This Challenge in the video · 5:28.
Quick answer: build a $250 bounty in a single state after Bandit 5 becomes active. One train robbery gets you most of the way at once.
| Bandit 5 | |
|---|---|
| Goal | $250 bounty in one state |
| Best location | Valentine, New Hanover |
| Fastest method | A train robbery plus a few crimes in the same state, or replaying The Sheep and the Goats |
| Honor | Depends on the crime; killing civilians or lawmen costs the most |
| Chapter 2? | Yes, once Bandit 4 is done |
| If it does not count | The whole $250 has to be earned after Bandit 5 is active, in one state |
| Reward | $10 and Dead Eye experience |
Choose one state and build the bounty there; I used Valentine. Commit a crime, let the law arrive and keep raising the bounty until it reaches $250. One state. $250. All of it after Bandit 5 is active. A bounty you already had does not count, and once the number hits $250, leave.
Easiest way: replay The Sheep and the Goats
A community method with later confirmations on Reddit: replay the mission The Sheep and the Goats from the Progress menu and build the $250 bounty there. It saves you from starting fights in town, although it is a player method rather than an official one.
Can you complete Bandit 5 in Chapter 2?
Yes. It only needs Bandit 4 finished, and the Emerald Ranch fence for Bandit 2 and 4 opens in Chapter 2. The Challenge that has to wait for Chapter 3 is Bandit 6.
Bandit Challenge 5 not working?
Check three things: Bandit 5 was already the active rank when the bounty started, all of it is in the same state, and the $250 is the bounty on that state rather than the sum of several. Paying off an old bounty before you start makes the count easier to read.
Honor: avoid killing to build the bounty if you care about Arthur’s Honor.
Bandit 6: steal five horses and sell them at Clemens Cove
This Challenge in the video · 6:08.
You need the Clemens Cove horse fence, northwest of Rhodes, which opens after Horse Flesh for Dinner in Chapter 3. Wait near the fence for a rider or a wagon, take the horse, sell it and repeat. You can also unhitch horses from some wagons and sell them one by one.
The calmer method from my video is to calm and break wild horses in The Heartlands and bring them to Clemens Cove. Five horses sold and you are done.
Honor: stealing a horse costs a little. Breaking wild horses involves no theft, so it should not cost any Honor.
Reward: $15 and Dead Eye experience. RDR2.org
Bandit 7: rob $50 from townsfolk and travelers
Master Roshi TechniqueThis Challenge in the video · 7:14.
You can rob people one by one, but a train is faster because passengers carry more money than random townsfolk:
- Buy a ticket from Valentine to Riggs Station.
- Climb onto the engine from the driver’s side and take control.
- Drive onto Bard’s Crossing and stop on the large railroad bridge.
- Deal with the guards and rob passengers until the counter reaches $50.
The bridge makes it harder for lawmen to reach you and buys time, though it does not guarantee a robbery without a bounty; law behavior can vary between versions and playthroughs. Use it to buy time, and don’t count on it making the robbery invisible.
Honor: every passenger you rob costs some.
Reward: the Bandit Off-Hand Holster at the Trapper.
Bandit 8: steal seven wagons and sell them at Emerald Ranch
This Challenge in the video · 8:25.
Stagecoaches count as wagons, so go back to the Emerald Ranch fence and repeat the Bandit 2 loop seven times: coach from Valentine, steal it on arrival, sell it. Any wagon stolen on the nearby roads also counts, and the closer you steal it to the fence, the less time you spend driving a stolen vehicle.
Seven wagons. Seven sales.
Honor: each stolen wagon costs some, and seven of them add up.
Reward: $15 and Dead Eye experience. RDR2.org
Bandit 9: hogtie someone and leave them on the railroad three times
Quick and easyThis Challenge in the video · 8:58.
You do not need a train to arrive. Go to Emerald Ranch station, where there are usually people next to the tracks. Lasso someone, hogtie them, pick them up and place them on the rails. If they get free, tie them again and put them back. You don’t need three victims: the same person can count all three times.
Honor: this is the Challenge that can cost the least. The big Honor loss would come from a death, so take them off the tracks before a train comes and nobody should get hurt.
Reward: $20 and Dead Eye experience. RDR2.org
Bandit 10: complete five train robberies without dying or being caught
Master Roshi TechniqueThis Challenge in the video · 9:29.
Quick answer: rob one passenger per train, get off and lose the law. Five clean robberies without dying or being caught complete it, and if the counter stops, let an in-game day pass.
It looks long and it can be very short, because robbing a single passenger can be enough for the robbery to count. You do not need to clear the train or open every safe. Reuse the Bandit 7 setup: ride from Valentine to Riggs Station, take the engine, stop on Bard’s Crossing, deal with the guards, rob one passenger, get off and lose the law. Then do the next train.
Easiest way to complete Bandit Challenge 10
Steam players report an even shorter version: wait for a train to stop at a station, open the chest on one of its open flatcars and get off immediately. For some players that already adds a robbery. If it does not count for you, go back to one passenger per train, which is the method from my video. One is enough.
When can you do it, and what is the reward?
From Chapter 3, because Bandit 6 needs the Clemens Cove horse fence. The reward is the Gun Belt at the Trapper, and finishing Bandit 10 completes the branch for Legend of the East.
Bandit Challenge 10 not counting?
If you die or are caught during the robbery, it does not count. In my playthrough I also had to let one in-game day pass before the counter would increase again, so if back-to-back robberies stop counting, sleep or wait 24 in-game hours and check the counter before continuing. The recording mentions dying between attempts to get the counter moving, which goes against the objective, so use the wait instead.
Bandit 10 without losing Honor
Every train robbery costs some Honor. One passenger per train keeps the loss to the minimum, and as John in the Epilogue it does not touch Arthur’s ending.
Honor: can you do them without losing it?
Not all of them. Robbing people and stealing are dishonorable actions in RDR2, and Bandit is built on exactly that, so the complete set will always cost Arthur some Honor. On Steam, players who have finished the set put it plainly: there is no way through Bandit without losing Honor. What you can choose is when you pay and how quickly you recover.
- Recover as you go. Greeting people, releasing the fish you catch, helping strangers in random encounters, donating to the camp tithing box and paying off your bounties all raise Honor. Greeting is slow but free: one player counts roughly one tick per three greetings.
- Pick the cheap methods. Wild horses for Bandit 6, one passenger per train for Bandit 7 and 10 and nobody dying in Bandit 5 and 9.
- Leave them for the Epilogue. As John, the robberies do not touch Arthur’s Honor or his ending. The exception is Legend of the East as Arthur, which needs every Challenge done with him; this guide explains that route.
Honor matters most at the end of Chapter 6, where it decides which version of Arthur’s ending you get. The endings guide explains what changes.
Why a Bandit Challenge is not counting
- It is not the active rank yet. Challenges unlock in order and only the current one counts. For Bandit 5, a bounty you had before it became active does not count.
- The day changed. Bandit 3 and Bandit 4 need all their robberies in the same in-game day; if a new day starts, the count starts again.
- The fence is not open. Emerald Ranch needs The Spines of America (Chapter 2) and Clemens Cove needs Horse Flesh for Dinner (Chapter 3).
- The action is incomplete. In Bandit 2 stealing the coach is not enough: rob its chest or sell it, and use a normal stagecoach rather than one from a special job. In Bandit 6 the horses have to be sold at Clemens Cove.
- Bandit 10. If you die or are caught during the robbery it does not count, and back-to-back robberies may need an in-game day in between.
Check the real progress in the Challenges section of the Progress menu before repeating anything.
Bandit rewards
Four ranks unlock reinforced Bandit gear at the Trapper and the other six give a little cash and Dead Eye experience. The guides I checked don’t give the exact amount of experience. Completing all ten also counts toward Legend of the East, which needs rank 10 in every Challenge category. RDR2.org
| Rank | Reward |
|---|---|
| Bandit 1 | Bandolier (Trapper) |
| Bandit 2 | $5 and Dead Eye experience |
| Bandit 3 | Holster (Trapper) |
| Bandit 4 | $10 and Dead Eye experience |
| Bandit 5 | $10 and Dead Eye experience |
| Bandit 6 | $15 and Dead Eye experience |
| Bandit 7 | Off-Hand Holster (Trapper) |
| Bandit 8 | $15 and Dead Eye experience |
| Bandit 9 | $20 and Dead Eye experience |
| Bandit 10 | Gun Belt (Trapper) |
Short route for all ten
If I did the whole set again: Valentine for people and registers, Emerald Ranch for coaches and wagons, Clemens Cove for horses and the trains for the $50 and the five robberies. Bandit 10 looks like five large train heists. Don’t give them that much: take the minimum that moves the counter and leave.
Frequently asked questions
When can I finish every Bandit Challenge?
From Chapter 3, when the Clemens Cove horse fence opens for Bandit 6.
Can I do the Bandit Challenges without losing Honor?
Not the full set. Bandit 9 can cost nothing if nobody dies, and wild horses avoid theft in Bandit 6, but the robberies always cost Honor. Recover it by greeting people, releasing fish and donating to camp, or leave the set for John in the Epilogue.
Why is my Bandit Challenge not counting?
Usually because it is not the active rank yet, you robbed shops or travelers instead of townsfolk in Bandit 1, the in-game day changed in Bandit 3 or 4, the fence is not open yet, or in Bandit 10 you died or were caught.
What are the rewards for the Bandit Challenges?
The Bandolier (Bandit 1), Holster (Bandit 3), Off-Hand Holster (Bandit 7) and Gun Belt (Bandit 10) at the Trapper. The rest pay between $5 and $20 plus Dead Eye experience; Bandit 5, for example, pays $10.
Where should I do Bandit 1?
In Valentine: the law is easier to escape than in Saint Denis or Blackwater, and there are plenty of people for the five holdups.
What is the fast Bandit 2 method?
Take a coach from Valentine to Emerald Ranch, steal that same coach when you arrive, rob its chest if it has one and sell it to the nearby fence.
Where should I do Bandit 3?
Three registers in Valentine and the fourth in Strawberry, on the same day. Start early, because shops close.
Can the Bandit 5 bounty be split across states?
No. You need $250 in a single state.
Where do I sell the Bandit 6 horses?
At the Clemens Cove horse fence, northwest of Rhodes, which opens in Chapter 3.
What is the fast Bandit 7 method?
Rob passengers on a train stopped on the Bard’s Crossing bridge until the counter reaches $50.
Do I need three victims for Bandit 9?
No. The same person counts three times if you hogtie them and put them back on the tracks.
Do I need to rob the entire train for Bandit 10?
No. Robbing one passenger can be enough.
More Challenge guides
Sources
Daykyri’s video guide, published November 2018.
Red Dead Wiki — single-player Challenges.
Red Dead Wiki — fences and unlock requirements.
PowerPyx — Challenge requirements.
Push Square — how to gain and lose Honor.
RDR2.org — rewards for each Bandit Challenge.
Accelerated Ideas — Honor points by activity.
Steam Community — Bandit Challenges and Honor.
Steam Community — Bandit 1 counts people, not shops.
Steam Community — routes for Bandit 3.
Reddit, r/RDR2 — special-job coaches and Bandit 2.
Reddit, r/reddeadredemption — Bandit 5 with The Sheep and the Goats.
GameFAQs — Bandit Challenge not unlocking.
Steam Community — Bandit 10 shortcut.
Last verified: October 7, 2026.