dKDaykyri
Red Dead Redemption 2 RDR2ChallengesHorseman

RDR2 Horseman Challenges: How to Complete All 10

Use the railroad for Strawberry to Saint Denis, Owanjila Dam for the dry Blackwater route, Bayou Nwa for predators and tame nine wild breeds for Horseman 10.

Challenges
10
Horseman 3
Valentine → Rhodes
Horseman 8
Bayou Nwa
Horseman 10
9 wild breeds
Arthur Morgan riding a horse along a country road in Red Dead Redemption 2
Arthur Morgan on horseback in Red Dead Redemption 2.

Horseman mixes very easy Challenges with two routes where one bad turn sends you back to the start.

The ones that matter:

ChallengeMethod
Horseman 3Valentine to Rhodes along the railroad, under 5 minutes
Horseman 6Strawberry, Riggs Station and the tracks to Saint Denis
Horseman 8Alligators at Bayou Nwa
Horseman 9Van Horn to Blackwater across Owanjila Dam
Horseman 10Break all nine wild breeds

For Horseman 6 and 9:

Bridges yes. Water no.

Rivers, creeks and puddles the game registers as water break the attempt. Rain doesn’t count. RDR2.org

Horseman 1 — kill five rabbits from horseback

Very easy.

Ride through The Heartlands or Bolger Glade, where rabbits are more common.

Bring the Varmint Rifle.

When you see a rabbit:

  1. don’t dismount;
  2. chase it;
  3. aim;
  4. fire.

Five rabbits. RDR2.org

Horseman 2 — jump over three obstacles in 15 seconds

You need a line of fences with room to build speed.

The Grey and Braithwaite properties south of Rhodes have plenty, according to RDR2.org. Emerald Ranch works too. RDR2.org

Method

  1. Line up in front of a row of fences.
  2. Start galloping.
  3. Clear the first one.
  4. Keep going straight.
  5. Clear two more within 15 seconds.

You don’t need three different kinds of obstacle.

Three fences do it. An Arabian, with its handling, makes it easier.

Horseman 3 — ride from Valentine to Rhodes in under five minutes

You don’t need a special horse.

One with a good bond and some stamina makes it with time to spare.

Before you leave

  • fill the stamina core;
  • carry a stimulant in your satchel;
  • make a manual save.

Route

Leave the Valentine train station heading south to the railroad.

Follow it at full gallop to Rhodes. RDR2.org

Avoid:

  • fights;
  • random encounters;
  • falls;
  • dismounting.

Check the map before you set off. The clock runs while you look at it.

Horseman 4 — drag a victim 3,300 feet with your lasso while mounted

The victim has to be alive when you rope them.

They don’t have to stay alive.

Method

  1. Look for smoke from an enemy camp.
  2. Leave just one alive.
  3. Rope them from the saddle.
  4. Hold the lasso.
  5. Ride across open ground.
  6. Keep going until the Challenge pops.

Don’t dismount.

Don’t let go of the lasso.

An enemy, away from the roads, saves you witnesses and trouble with the law. RDR2.org

Horseman 5 — trample five animals

The animal has to die from the trampling.

Only small animals count:

  • rabbits;
  • squirrels;
  • frogs;
  • turtles.

Bolger Glade is full of rabbits. The Bayou Nwa swamps, of frogs and turtles. RDR2.org

Point your horse at them.

Gallop.

Horseman 6 — Strawberry to Saint Denis in under nine minutes without touching water

Quick and easy

The easy route uses the tracks.

Before you leave

Bring:

  • horse stimulants;
  • a full stamina core;
  • a horse with a good bond.

Save your game.

Route

  1. Start in Strawberry.
  2. Set the marker on Riggs Station.
  3. When you get there, ride onto the tracks.
  4. Cross Bard’s Crossing on the railroad bridge.
  5. When the tracks split, switch the marker to Saint Denis.
  6. Follow the tracks east.
  7. Reach the city in under nine minutes. RDR2.org

A clean run leaves time to spare.

Don’t cross Dewberry Creek just anywhere

Even where it looks dry, some spots count as water.

The tracks and bridges take that doubt away.

Watch for trains

Before you ride onto a long bridge, check whether one is coming.

Losing the Challenge hurts.

Losing your horse hurts more.

Horseman 7 — kill seven enemies from horseback without dismounting

There’s no time limit.

You just have to stay in the saddle for all seven kills.

Good spots

  • story missions;
  • O’Driscoll camps;
  • the Lemoyne Raiders;
  • the hideout north of Valentine, by Cumberland Forest. RDR2.org

Method

  1. Stay mounted.
  2. Keep your distance.
  3. Use Dead Eye.
  4. Take enemies down one by one.
  5. Don’t dismount until you hit seven.

If your horse panics, calm it.

Don’t ride into the middle of the camp if you can shoot from outside.

Horseman 8 — kill nine predators from horseback

Quick and easy

Head to Bayou Nwa, in the swamps north of Saint Denis.

Alligators are perfect.

There are lots of them.

They’re big.

And they don’t charge you like a cougar.

Method

  1. Stay on your horse.
  2. Keep your distance from the alligators.
  3. Use a scoped rifle with Dead Eye: one headshot isn’t enough to kill an alligator.
  4. Kill nine.

You don’t have to do it in one go.

The other option is to set predator bait in a forest and drop whatever comes from range. RDR2.org

Don’t ride over them

Your horse has an opinion about that.

It usually expresses it by throwing you off.

Horseman 9 — Van Horn to Blackwater in under 17 minutes without touching water

Plan this one before you leave.

Seventeen minutes is enough time.

The problem is water.

Before you set off

  • your fastest, highest-stamina horse;
  • plenty of stimulants;
  • full cores;
  • a manual save. RDR2.org

You don’t need the fastest horse in the game.

You need not to crash.

Arthur Morgan riding along a country road in Red Dead Redemption 2 Arthur Morgan on horseback in an official Red Dead Redemption 2 image. Rockstar Games.

Safe route

Quick and easy
  1. Start in Van Horn.
  2. Head south.
  3. Cross into The Heartlands on bridges and dry ground.
  4. Pass Flatneck Station.
  5. Cross the Dakota River at Bard’s Crossing.
  6. Pass Riggs Station.
  7. Head toward Owanjila.
  8. Cross the Upper Montana at Owanjila Dam.
  9. Ride down through Tall Trees.
  10. Pass Manzanita Post.
  11. Cross the Great Plains.
  12. Ride into Blackwater.

Owanjila Dam is the key part.

The bridge gets you over the Upper Montana without your horse touching water.

RDR2.org suggests a variant: leave from the Van Horn coach signpost toward Emerald Ranch, follow the tracks through Valentine to Riggs Station and cross at Owanjila Dam as well. RDR2.org

Don’t try to save a minute by fording a river.

You have time.

Horseman 9 as Arthur

You can do it as Arthur.

It’s much more dangerous, because Blackwater, Tall Trees and the Great Plains are still restricted.

The law comes for you the moment you reach town, and the last stretch turns into a mess.

RDR2.org recommends waiting until after Chapter 6. RDR2.org

If you’re going for Legend of the East as Arthur, use the dedicated route.

Horseman 10 — break every required wild horse breed

The Challenge asks for nine wild breeds.

Not every horse in the game.

You don’t need an Arabian.

You don’t need a Thoroughbred.

How to break a horse

  1. Save first if it’s a rare breed.
  2. Approach slowly and calm the herd.
  3. Rope the horse while it’s calm.
  4. Mount it.
  5. Keep your balance by leaning away from where it tries to throw you.
  6. Hold on until the broken notice appears.

You don’t have to take it to a stable.

Once the game registers the breed, move on to the next.

Horses only count with Horseman 10 active. RDR2.org PowerPyx

All nine breeds

BreedAs ArthurIn the Epilogue
American PaintRare, near Donner FallsSouth of Tumbleweed
American StandardbredNorth of Cumberland Forest and Little Creek River in Big ValleyNear Mercer Station
AppaloosaNear the Wapiti reservation and Cattail PondNear Cholla Springs
Hungarian HalfbredAround Blackwater, a restricted areaAround Blackwater and east of Cholla Springs
Kentucky SaddlerBraithwaite Manor, Rhodes and Cattail PondSouthwest of Blackwater and Lake Don Julio
MorganCumberland Forest, Little Creek River and Riggs StationVery common in New Austin
MustangCentral HeartlandsWest of Fort Mercer
NokotaCentral HeartlandsSouth of Armadillo and near Fort Mercer
Tennessee WalkerThe Heartlands and the Wapiti reservationNear Blackwater and Armadillo

Spawns are random.

Use binoculars and study the horse to see its breed.

If a different one shows up:

  1. ride away;
  2. sleep or reload;
  3. come back. PowerPyx

The Challenge tracks your breeds.

Before spending an hour hunting a Mustang, check whether you already have it.

There are nine.

After the seventh, they all start to look alike.

Horseman route

1–5: around Valentine, Rhodes and Bolger Glade.

6: the tracks to Saint Denis.

7: an enemy camp.

8: alligators.

9: Owanjila Dam.

10: nine breeds.

Unlocks

RankTrapper gear
Horseman 1Gun belt
Horseman 3Holster
Horseman 7Bandolier
Horseman 10Off-hand holster

The other ranks give cash and Stamina XP. Completing the set gives a Health bonus. RDR2.org

Frequently asked questions

What’s the Horseman 6 route?

Strawberry, Riggs Station, the tracks over Bard’s Crossing and the tracks to Saint Denis.

Can I touch water in Horseman 6?

No. Use bridges.

Which animals count for Horseman 5?

Only small animals: rabbits, squirrels, frogs and turtles.

Where do I do Horseman 8?

At Bayou Nwa: alligators count as predators and there are lots of them together.

Where do I cross for Horseman 9?

At Owanjila Dam, to get over the Upper Montana without touching water.

Can I do Horseman 9 as Arthur?

Yes, but the Blackwater area is hostile and the attempt is much more dangerous.

How many breeds does Horseman 10 need?

Nine. You don’t need the Arabian.

Do I have to stable every horse I break?

No. Break it until the game registers the breed and move on to the next.


More Challenge guides

All RDR2 Challenges

Herbalist

Survivalist

The best horses in RDR2

Legend of the East as Arthur

RDR2 100% Completion


Sources

RDR2.org — Horseman Challenges Guide, part 1

RDR2.org — Horseman Challenges Guide, part 2

PowerPyx — Wild Horse Breed Locations

GameFAQs — Horseman Challenges

Red Dead Wiki — Horseman Challenges

Last verified: October 17, 2026.