dKDaykyri
Red Dead Redemption 2 RDR2EndingsHonorArthur MorganMicah

RDR2 Endings: All 4 Arthur Endings and How to Get Them

RDR2 combines two factors to create four Arthur endings: High or Low Honor and the final choice between helping John or returning for the money.

Arthur's endings
4
Depend on
Honor and choice
Final choice
John or the money
Reading
Contains spoilers
Silhouette of a rider on horseback against the setting sun in Red Dead Redemption 2
A rider at sunset in Red Dead Redemption 2.

SPOILERS: this guide covers the end of Chapter 6 and part of the Epilogue.

Red Dead Redemption 2 has four versions of Arthur’s ending.

They come from combining two things:

  1. your Honor;
  2. the final choice: help John or go back for the money.

Arthur dies in all four. What changes is how.

The Epilogue with John continues either way. SegmentNext

ChoiceHigh HonorLow Honor
Help JohnArthur dies peacefully watching the sunriseMicah shoots Arthur
Go back for the moneyArthur dies of his wounds and illnessMicah finishes Arthur with a knife

How the ending is decided

The decision comes in Chapter 6’s final mission:

Red Dead Redemption.

When the gang falls apart, the game makes you choose:

  • Help John get to safety
  • Go back for the money

Your Honor level then decides how Arthur’s story ends.

It also decides which vision he has before the credits.

Helping John with high Honor

This is the ending most players consider the best for Arthur.

Choose help John and reach the mission with high Honor.

What happens

Arthur covers John’s escape.

He gives him his hat and sends him to his family.

Then he fights Micah on the mountain.

Dutch arrives during the fight.

Arthur tells him Micah is the rat and reminds him that he tried to change.

Dutch leaves. Micah leaves too.

Arthur, very sick by now, drags himself to a rock.

He watches the sunrise.

He dies there, with the deer vision. SegmentNext

Helping John with low Honor

The route starts the same way: help John.

The difference is your Honor.

What happens

Arthur gets John to go on without him.

He fights Micah.

Dutch shows up and abandons them both.

Then Micah walks up to Arthur.

He shoots him in the head and leaves.

The vision that comes with this ending is the wolf.

It’s one of the darkest versions.

Going back for the money with high Honor

Choose go back for the money, with high Honor.

Arthur returns to the Beaver Hollow cave.

What happens

Arthur goes for the gang’s money.

Micah attacks him.

It’s a knife fight, and it ends in a draw.

Dutch arrives.

Arthur insists Micah is the rat.

Dutch leaves.

Micah takes the money and walks away without finishing him off.

Arthur is left alone and dies of his wounds and his illness as the sun comes up, with the deer vision. SegmentNext

Going back for the money with low Honor

This is the most violent combination.

Choose go back for the money and arrive with low Honor.

What happens

Same fight at Beaver Hollow.

This time Micah wins the struggle.

He finishes Arthur with the knife, with the wolf vision.

And choosing the money still won’t let you start the Epilogue with the loot.

All four endings at a glance

EndingChoiceHonorArthur
1Help JohnHighDies peacefully at sunrise
2Help JohnLowMicah shoots him
3Go back for the moneyHighDies of his wounds at sunrise
4Go back for the moneyLowMicah stabs him

Which ending is best?

If you want the most redemptive close for Arthur:

High Honor + help John.

Arthur spends his last minutes making sure John gets back to his family.

And he gets the sunrise scene.

Rockstar has never named a canon ending.

Roger Clark, Arthur’s actor, has his own: “going back to help John, with high Honor, for me is my canon ending.” He adds that he sees little point in going back for the money when Arthur’s time is so short. RDR2.org

The most brutal one?

Low Honor + go back for the money.

The deer and the wolf

Once Arthur learns he’s sick, his Honor shows in how he takes it.

With high Honor he accepts it almost serenely.

With low Honor he takes it harder, though he still resolves to help John and his family.

At certain moments he has visions:

  • a deer with high Honor;
  • a wolf with low Honor.

The same vision returns at the end. RDR2.org

Can I raise Honor right before the ending?

Yes.

Chapter 6 gives you plenty of chances. You can:

  • greet people;
  • help strangers;
  • release fish;
  • finish optional missions;
  • show mercy.

If you’re near the middle of the meter, don’t leave it to the last second.

Raise it before Our Best Selves.

Make a save before Our Best Selves

Quick and easy

If you want to see several versions:

Before Our Best Selves: save. That’s the save you want to keep.

After that, the story enters its final stretch.

From that save you can go back, change the decision and set up a different Honor level.

Replaying just the final mission shows you the other choice at your current Honor.

For the opposite-Honor versions, that earlier save is far more practical.

Promotional art of Arthur Morgan aiming a revolver with the gang behind him in Red Dead Redemption 2 Arthur Morgan in Red Dead Redemption 2 promotional art. Rockstar Games.

The horse bond scene

The final mission has an extra scene.

It only plays if your horse is at max bond.

If that matters to you, look after the horse you’ll finish the story with. RDR2.org

Does the choice change the Epilogue?

The Epilogue with John goes ahead in all four endings.

The big later missions are still there.

Arthur’s money doesn’t pass to John either, and choosing the money doesn’t fix that.

There’s a well-known community method with Aberdeen Pig Farm: you leave the stolen money there as Arthur and collect it later as John.

It works whichever ending you pick.

Years later, John, Sadie and Charles track Micah to Mount Hagen.

That’s where the Epilogue ends, and its final scenes tie into what leads to Red Dead Redemption.

Does Arthur always die?

Yes.

His last minutes change. Arthur dies in all four versions.

There’s no official route where he survives Chapter 6.

No secret fifth ending either.

Micah, on the other hand, always survives Chapter 6: his story continues in the Epilogue, in American Venom.

The 100% cutscene

When you reach 100% Total Completion, the game unlocks an exclusive cutscene with John Marston.

It’s the only in-game reward for 100%.

It works as an extra coda and leaves all four endings as they are. GTABase

The full list is in the 100% guide.

My recommendation for a first playthrough

If you’re playing Arthur as someone trying to make something right before he dies:

raise your Honor and help John.

If you want to see the rest afterward:

save before Our Best Selves.

And try the other three.

Frequently asked questions

How many endings does RDR2 have?

Arthur has four versions.

They come from combining high or low Honor with helping John or going back for the money.

Which ending is best?

High Honor and helping John.

It’s also the one Roger Clark considers his canon ending.

Can Arthur survive?

No.

What happens if I go back for the money?

Arthur returns to Beaver Hollow and knife-fights Micah.

With high Honor he dies of his wounds. With low Honor, Micah finishes him.

Do I keep the money?

No. You can’t use it later.

What happens with low Honor?

Micah kills Arthur on both routes: with a gunshot if you help John and with the knife if you go back for the money.

Does the choice change the Epilogue?

No. The Epilogue with John exists in every case.

Where should I save?

Before Our Best Selves.


More RDR2 guides

RDR2 100% Completion

Every Missable in RDR2

RDR1 or RDR2 first

RDR2 Compendium


Sources

SegmentNext — Red Dead Redemption 2 endings

RDR2.org — Roger Clark’s canon ending

RDR2.org — Endings Guide

GTABase — RDR2 100% Completion Guide

GTA Series Videos — all four endings compared

Red Dead Wiki — Arthur Morgan

Last verified: October 17, 2026.